>>182>some tricks I can use to make melodies that don't sound too shittylike
>>184 was saying, any notes that are in the underlying chord will work just fine for a melody. but if thats
all you do, your melody will be very boring and gay.
so lets ruminate on what a melody is, and what its purpose is in music, and to a minor extent, what music even is
so...
>what is music? bear with me here for a secat its most basic, it is a series of sounds that create tension and release in a listener. well composed music will have every one of its parts, from the rhythm, to the harmony, to the melody, the timbre/tone, even the song structure be crafted in a way to build tension and then eventually release it
>what is a melody?the thing you sing along to. not always a vocal part obviously, but it is the thing that you would hum to someone if trying to recall a song. in this sense, melody is perhaps the most important part of the music to the average listener
not talking about modern pop obviously. more rhythm if anything (there aint much to it tbh). if thinking of music instead as a painting, melody would be the lines. harmony, the colors. rhythm being the background, frame, type of canvas, or overall feel of the piece. and timbre being the type of paint
melody is also notable for being the only one that can stand alone, and still
actually be a "song" in the technical sense.
harmony and rhythm, while definitely not unimportant, if played by themselves could be
any number of songs or progressions or beats.
but they are not clearly a specific "song". you sing a melody by itself, and it will be instantly recognizable
lotta flowery bullshit, i know, but its helpful to understand why were doing some of these next things, in regards to actually making a melody
so now onto the major """"rules""""
as with all rules in theory, read: "extremely vague guidelines"A MELODY MUST BE SINGABLEvery important, as the purpose of the melody is just that: to let the listener sing along, aloud or in their heads. they aint gonna sing the chords, unless theyre mongolian throat singers, and no one "sings" drum parts
maybe hiphop? they still tend to alter their pitch to create tension/emphasis tho so its debatable. i suppose punk bands do this a lot toosome ways you can keep a melody singable:
>not too many large jumps. large leaps are generally much harder to perform on any instrument, and many vocalists will have a hard limit on the range they can reliably jump. this increases the chance of your melody being mangled or not "popping out" properly, and is a general composition no-no<not too fast. if it goes by way too fast, it will be hard to discern what it even is, coming across more like a sheet of sound, or a blur/smudge, than a clearly drawn "line">mostly consonant in terms of notes ie not dissonant. you would do this by mostly sticking to notes in the underlying chords or scales. adding notes outside of this is very important ill prolly get into this later, but it must be done tastefully. too much dissonance and no one will be able to sing it, and most everyone will prolly hate it tooA MELODY MUST BE MEMORABLEthis can mean a lot of things, some examples being:
>not too terribly complex see above. tho if its too boring, it becomes forgettable which is just as bad. so you gotta split the difference<have some sort of a repetition to it. if the melody is too long, it will be hard to remember. too much repetition, and your melody becomes an "ostinato", which is essentially a pitched type of rhythm. again, one must find a happy medium>have something to grab the attention of the listenernow i know this one^^^ is super vague, but its very important. a really well written pop song will have the melody stuck in your head almost immediately. some examples are
<using dynamics to emphasize certain parts>using "hooks" look up "pop hook" if you dont know what i meanetc...